The Intrinsic Value Podcast discusses DoorDash, a US market leader in meal delivery, and its ambitious expansion to become a logistics company for all local commerce – dubbed the "FedEx of local retail." Hosts Sean O'Malley and Daniel Munker explore DoorDash's journey, highlighting its transition from a cash-burning startup to a recently profitable enterprise.
DoorDash's origin traces back to a Stanford class project, Palo Alto Delivery, where founders personally delivered orders for local businesses that couldn't afford their own drivers. This early "hustle" and creative use of smartphone tech (like "Find My Friends" for dispatch) laid the groundwork. Their unique strategy involved targeting suburban markets, which competitors like Grubhub and Uber Eats overlooked in favor of city centers. Suburbs offered less competition, larger order sizes (families vs. individuals), and easier logistics, positioning DoorDash for massive growth during the 2020 pandemic.
However, the company's history isn't without controversy. A 2019 New York Times report revealed that DoorDash was factoring customer tips into driver minimum earnings, effectively suppressing Dasher pay and misleading customers. While this policy was later changed, it raised ethical concerns about the company's "win at all costs" mentality. Despite this, CEO Tony Xu is praised for his hands-on approach, regularly engaging with customer support to understand operational challenges.
DoorDash has diversified its revenue streams beyond just commissions from restaurants and delivery fees from customers. "DoorDash Drive" offers a white-label service, allowing restaurants to use DoorDash's logistics network for their own online orders, preserving merchant relationships. Advertising has become a significant, high-margin revenue source, contributing to a rising "take rate" (net revenue margin) from 10% in 2018 to 13.4% today. Subscriptions like "DashPass" drive customer loyalty and order frequency, improving unit economics through better order batching.
The gig economy model, classifying drivers as independent contractors, is crucial to DoorDash's profitability. This model, despite regulatory pressures in some cities (e.g., New York's minimum earnings), saves costs compared to employing drivers with benefits. The hosts suggest that societal acceptance of convenience outweighs calls for reclassification, especially given the increased prices it would entail.
DoorDash is also venturing into "first-party" retail with "Dash Marts" – warehouses stocking inventory for rapid delivery of various goods, akin to Amazon's logistics. They've also been acquisitive, buying Caviar for high-end delivery, Wolt for European expansion ($8.1B), and Deliveroo for UK/European market share ($3.9B). A recent acquisition of SevenRooms, a hospitality tech company, aims to deepen relationships with restaurants by offering CRM and analytics, diversifying beyond just delivery. While M&A can be risky, these deals expand DoorDash's geographic reach and strategic offerings.
From a valuation perspective, the podcast notes DoorDash's large addressable market ($3 trillion each for restaurants and groceries globally). With current gross order volume (GOV) at $80 billion, projecting a mature GOV of $300 billion (5% of the total market), a 13% take rate would yield $39 billion in revenue. Assuming a 15% operating margin, this could result in $6 billion in operating profit. Applying typical market multiples (25-35x operating profit) suggests a future valuation of $150-$210 billion.
However, the hosts conclude that despite DoorDash's impressive growth and strategic moves, the stock, currently around a $100 billion valuation, is "priced for perfection." High stock-based compensation (9-10% of revenue) and resulting shareholder dilution (share count up a third in 5 years) are significant concerns. Even with optimistic growth projections, the implied annual return (8-12%) fails to meet their 12% hurdle rate, especially considering the rapid growth rates seen during the pandemic may not be sustainable. Therefore, they pass on investing in DoorDash for now, believing the risk-reward profile is not skewed in their favor at current prices.