Millennial Investing - The Investor’s Podcast Network - MI374: Fortune’s Formula: The Scientific Betting System For Beating Wall Street w/ Shawn O’Malley
This podcast episode explores "Fortune's Formula," or the Kelly Formula, a scientific approach to making optimal bets in situations involving uncertainty, risk, and financial payouts, whether in gambling or investing. The host, Sean O'Malley, emphasizes that while investing isn't gambling, both share fundamental similarities and can benefit from a disciplined betting strategy. The episode draws heavily from William Poundstone's book, "Fortune's Formula," highlighting the stories of its creators and practitioners.
The formula originated in 1956 at Bell Labs, discovered by physicist John L. Kelly Jr. and mathematician Claude Shannon, widely considered the "father of the digital age" and information theory. Shannon, a genius whose IQ rivaled Einstein's, fundamentally changed the world by devising binary coding – the language of computers – and his seminal 1948 paper, "A Mathematical Theory of Communication." Their application of information theory aimed at maximizing financial gains.
Shannon later teamed up with MIT mathematician and legendary investor Ed Thorpe. Thorpe, a child prodigy with a photographic memory, became obsessed with beating blackjack. He used MIT's mainframe computer to calculate odds, revealing that tracking played "five cards" could significantly tilt the odds in a player's favor. His 1962 book, "Beat the Dealer," revolutionized card counting. Together, Shannon and Thorpe even designed a wearable computer to predict roulette outcomes, giving them a formidable 44% edge.
However, having an edge wasn't enough; they needed an optimal betting strategy. This is where John Kelly's formula came in. Kelly studied pari-mutuel betting at horse races to determine the ideal amount to wager. The Kelly Formula dictates betting "X percent of your bankroll on a favorable bet" based on the ratio of your "edge" (how much you expect to win, given your superior assessment of true probabilities) over the "odds" (the market-implied payout). Crucially, the formula only works if you possess a genuine, superior insight into the probabilities, an "edge." Without it, the formula advises betting nothing. This principle explains why legendary investors like Warren Buffett take concentrated bets: their high conviction stems from a perceived superior understanding, or edge, of a company.
The formula’s ethical ambiguity is acknowledged, as Kelly often used examples of rigged horse races to illustrate an "edge." The host clarifies that while an illegal "insider's edge" is one form, a legitimate edge can also come from superior analytical skills or deep understanding derived from experience.
Thorpe rigorously tested the Kelly Formula in Las Vegas, using it to manage his bankroll while card counting. The formula's proportional betting strategy ensures that even during unlucky streaks, a bettor can never be completely wiped out, as nominal bet sizes shrink with losses. This contrasts sharply with "all or nothing" gamblers who invariably face ruin.
Shannon and Thorpe later applied the Kelly Formula to financial markets. Shannon, though initially indifferent to money, became a successful buy-and-hold investor, leveraging his industry knowledge (e.g., his significant investment in Teledyne, where he served on the board). Thorpe focused on stock options and convertible bonds. He developed models to identify mispriced options and, using "delta hedging" (buying the underlying stock to hedge against shorted options), created market-neutral arbitrage opportunities. His hedge fund, Princeton-Newport Partners, achieved stellar, low-volatility returns, far outpacing the S&P 500 for decades. Thorpe found that market inefficiencies, often due to "limits to arbitrage" like transaction costs and illiquidity, allowed these opportunities to persist.
The episode notes that while the specific strategies used by Thorpe in the 1970s are no longer novel, the underlying challenge for investors remains: finding a unique "edge" in today's increasingly efficient markets. The Kelly Formula itself, while theoretically maximizing long-term wealth and preventing ruin, is not without controversy. Its aggressive nature can lead to significant short-term volatility, prompting some to use a "half Kelly" approach to mitigate swings.
In conclusion, the Kelly Formula is presented as a powerful tool for capital allocation, rooted in the genius of its creators. It emphasizes the importance of understanding one's true "edge" and proportioning bets to maximize returns while safeguarding against catastrophic losses. The episode challenges listeners to consider what their own unique edge is in the investing world.