The "Intrinsic Value Podcast" episode dives deep into The Hershey Company (HSY), exploring its business, challenges, and valuation. Hershey, known for iconic brands like Reese's, Twizzlers, Kit Kats, and Hershey's Kisses, has seen its stock price fall significantly from a May 2023 peak, prompting the hosts, Sean O'Malley and Daniel Manka, to investigate if it's an attractive investment opportunity.
Daniel Manka notes Hershey's impressive financials, including stable gross margins around 45% and operating margins increasing to nearly 23%, despite soaring cocoa prices. The company also boasts a 3% dividend yield, 15% free cash flow margin, and over 20% ROIC. However, Sean highlights the "mixed picture," with success marred by rising input costs and potential demand shifts.
A major headwind for Hershey is the dramatic increase in cocoa prices, which hit a high of $14,000 per metric ton due to poor weather in West Africa, responsible for 70% of global supply. This supply chain vulnerability, exacerbated by climate change and socio-economic issues like child labor, poses a structural problem. Hershey attempts to mitigate this through hedging strategies, involving significant notional exposure to commodity futures and foreign exchange contracts. They also pass on costs through price increases (e.g., 67% on chocolate products in 2024). Long-term, Hershey invests in "Cocoa for Good," a $500 million initiative to ensure sustainable cocoa production and improve farmer livelihoods, which also serves to secure future supply. The growing demand for chocolate in China and the Chinese government's increasing involvement in African cocoa supply chains add another layer of competition for raw materials.
Another perceived threat is the rise of GLP-1 weight loss drugs. While management admits these drugs lead to disproportionately less consumption of their categories, they believe the current weakness in customer spending is primarily due to consumers trading down to cheaper, private-label snacks in response to inflation.
Hershey's unique ownership structure, where the Hershey Trust Company holds 80% of voting power with only 20% economic interest, has historically prevented takeovers. The Trust rejected bids from Mondelez (known for Oreo) in 2016 and more recently, partly because losing KitKat licensing rights (which would revert to Nestle if Hershey were sold) significantly devalues the offer from Hershey's perspective. The hosts discuss Milton Hershey's vision in establishing the Trust for charitable causes, but also acknowledge past controversies surrounding its management.
In terms of growth, Hershey, a mature company, expands through strategic acquisitions like Sour Strips and focusing on product innovation, such as Shaqalicious XL gummies and new Reese's varieties. Sean also highlights the competitive pressure from emerging "influencer" brands like Mr. Beast's chocolate, which leverages immense digital reach, a challenge for legacy brands with stronger regional biases. Operationally, Hershey aims for efficiency through its "AAA initiative," investing in SAP S4 HANA to digitize its product portfolio, optimize inventory, and forecast demand, expecting $300 million in annual savings by 2026.
Leadership changes also present uncertainty, with CEO Michelle Buck set to retire in 2026 and a key executive for the U.S. candy division recently quitting. Furthermore, the company faces increasing scrutiny over its role in public health issues like obesity and diabetes, with potential for stricter regulations and lawsuits.
Regarding pricing power, Sean references Warren Buffett's emphasis on this metric. While demand for Hershey's products is elastic (customers are sensitive to price), the company's strong brand recognition, nostalgia factor, and effective marketing allow it to maintain a 5-10% price premium over competitors. They also employ "shrinkflation" to implicitly raise prices. Hershey's brand power is a significant moat, making retailers prioritize stocking their products and difficult for new entrants to rival.
Despite a stronger-than-expected Q4 2024 earnings report, with net sales up 8.7% and net income more than doubling, the outlook for 2025 is challenging. Hershey's management forecasts gross profit margins to decline by seven percentage points and net income to fall by about 40% due to lagged effects of high cocoa prices, increased sugar and labor costs, and tariffs. Based on his discounted cash flow and P/E ratio analyses, Sean calculates a fair value of $130 per share. To account for risks and an adequate margin of safety, he suggests a buying price of $115 per share or less, significantly below its current trading price and past peak of $275.
Ultimately, both hosts conclude that while Hershey is a strong business with powerful brands, its current valuation does not offer a compelling investment opportunity. Sean also expresses personal reservations about investing in a company that contributes to global health issues, preferring companies that align with his values, like Vital Farms. They add Hershey to their watchlist, acknowledging it as a great business to understand, but not currently to own for their intrinsic value portfolio.